A Loudfence installation of pairs of shoes and ribbons in the Galilee Chapel of Durham Cathedral marked Safeguarding Sunday, inviting visitors to leave a message
or tie a ribbon.

Earlier this year an independent report on Safeguarding in the Church of England reported that a “small group of influential senior officers at the diocesan level and certain individuals within the national Church” were stalling efforts to move forwards.

Recently in the church’s General Synod the lead bishop for safeguarding, Bishop Robert Springett, was questioned about this and informed synod members that rather than finding others who were “critical inhibitors”, the challenge was to look inwards. “It’s easy to blame other people. Where am I being a critical inhibitor?” Bishop Springett preferred to use the report as a “good wake-up call to ask that question of ourselves” rather than launch a witch-hunt.

This is a wholly inadequate and imprecise response. The use of the term ‘witch-hunt’ is, of course, both emotive and manipulative. Bishop Springett could just as easily have said ‘we are not going to take action on this, we will not be finding out the inhibitors are.’

How do victims of abuse feel on reading this kind of weak response from the lead Bishop? Clearly it is not putting victims at the centre as many bishops claim to do, it is rather failing to address a serious problem. Victims constantly comment on the shabby way they are treated by church authority. Bishop Springett, the lead bishop on safeguarding, provides further evidence of this.

Yes, of course we all should look inwards, and ask ourselves questions. But shouldn’t we all, also, consider what is holding back progress in safeguarding and care of victims in the church? I would suggest to Bishop Springett that both can be done.

In my experience the significant problems are seldom at parish level but more at senior clergy and administrative level, and I have written about my personal experience of this in Manchester Diocese here, in which I describe senior people in the diocese protecting one another to ludicrous Kafka-esque proportions.

I am sure many in the pews would expect the church authorities to address those ‘influential senior officers’ hindering safeguarding at diocesan and national church level. Bishop Springett’s response could easily be interpreted as the powers that be protecting one another, in preference to caring for the survivors or victims.

Leave a Reply

Welcome to a retired rector’s reflections. My name is Ian Gomersall, and I’m a retired Anglican priest living in the North East of England. Here, I share my thoughts on a variety of things which interest me, some delight me, some anger me, and many are passing thoughts.

Thank you for being here, and I’d welcome your comments on thoughts through the comments box after a post.

Let’s connect